I am going to I guess challange, logically, a rule … that after research, I find to not be settled… I am talking about “Banking” or “Rathering”… I have now seen some sites list this as a basic Poker rule, while I did find sites alowing it. I almost pick’d up the phone and call’d 4-5 casinos in Vegas, but I have not done that yet…
From the wild west, where leaving the table the big winner early might get you shot… to Vegas, where most games were against the house, therefore its in the interest of a casino to want more chips in play… just cause its more likely the player will try and bet with them… So yes, it may be rude as hell to pull chips off the table between hands, but I see where its no more rude than someone attacking the short stack consistantly… but lets look @ this…
Currently, you can “auto-rebuy” and “auto-top off” … so why can’t you “anti-auto-rebuy” or “anti-auto-top off”… giving 1 segment of the players a advantage, without giving the opposide side … the same advantage… is creating a bias, that inherantly is unfair to 1 set of players.
If you told me that noone could auto-top off or auto-rebuy… basically I’m saying if you sit and lose your stack, then you must get up, get back in line to reseat at the table… paying the full buyin back onto the table … or you wouldn’t be able to lose 10%, then between hands add back in that 10% either … then fine, I might accept the fact that if I sit and win 10%, I can’t then “bank” that 10% between hands…
Lets also take the player that might buyin, then bust and rebuy 4 more times onto that ring table… he now has pumped 5x the buyin onto the table, if he wins 2x back yet can’t re-bank that… wouldn’t the limit here be … he couldn’t bank back more than 4x , untill he reaches the 4x, then must still sit with 1x the buyin… you see how crazy this gets…
Since Texas Hold’em is NOT against the house, then the idea of holding chips @ the table is then a factor of … yet again, a rule that is protecting some players while hurting other players… you can’t let ppl “auto-top off” and not let ppl “anti-auto-top off”.
Having said all of this, why would any poker site think this rule is awesome… simple… they want you to lose your chips as fast as possible and buy more… its purely financial…, they don’t want you to increase your bankroll…
Eliminate Auto-top off, eliminate rebuys… or allow banking of chips… Otherwise, you are giving someone an advantage, and taking away an advantage to the rest…