https://www.replaypoker.com/hand/replay/404794864
Here’s a hand I recently played at 5k/10k. It was the 3rd hand of the session against a player I knew nothing about (but who had lead out for pot after I raised in the previous hand).
A5s is a standard open 4-handed. BTN flats, and I am not assigning him a range pre because he is unknown.
Flop gives me top pair no kicker and backdoor nut flush draw. I check because I don’t get much value from worse and I can pick off the occasional bluff. I know everyone on Replay flats Ax, so I could be behind. He bets pot, which I hate but I have to call with top pair and having under-repped my hand by checking. Do you think it’s better to bet-fold instead because you set the price and can easily fold vs aggression?
Turn gives me flush draw (and more chop outs vs other aces). On a brick turn I would fold against a decent sized bet vs an unknown because I am usually outkicked. But the flush draw gives me many more outs. When he bets pot, this is where the hand gets interesting because it seems like all three options, fold, call, or shove are decent but none of them are great. If I give him exactly 2-pair plus (AA, JJ, 66, AK, AJ, A6) then I have 22% equity, which is a clear fold. Folding may be the best option because I can surely find better spots. But being a Replay unknown, I can give him say A5s+, A6o+, 66, JJ, AA), which I have 34% equity against. But then again, he would be left with just over half pot left behind. That makes shoving intriguing. With only 30% equity, I would need folds 13% of the time (5% with 34% equity) to break even, but based on the strength he showed, I am not counting on any folds. So I decided to just call with the expectation that I call some river shoves, especially if the board pairs. I got lucky to hit the river and managed to get paid off too. What would you do in this turn spot?
Edit: This analysis was based on my specific hand, but looking at my entire range, I think there are plenty of worse hands I could have folded on the flop, and once I call the flop there are still worse hands in my range that I can fold (e.g., A7o or A8 of clubs) and better hands to turn into a semi-bluff. I don’t really have any bluffs against this player in this spot, so my hand seemed like the right part of my range to call with (showdown value with a chance to improve). Are there other range-based factors I am missing?
Also, this hand is just a reminder that simply because someone “chases” a flush draw or plays passively postflop doesn’t mean they are just mindlessly clicking buttons.